Page 1

Click here to go to the Second Sold Lures page


Here are some of the old fishing lures I have sold in the past. You never know what I'm going to find, so be sure to check back often and maybe you'll be the happy owner of one of the rare old time beauties I'll have next!

If you have any old lures you want to sell (whether it's one, a small collection, or large collection) shoot me an email at brian@toughlures.com with what you have because I might be interested and pay better than many other collectors out there!




To sign up for our monthly email showing new
lures available, please enter your name and email address
in the boxes below then click on "SIGN ME UP!"

Name: Email Address:


Creek Chub Strawberry Spot Wigglefish SOLD!

Outing Green Scale Pikey Getum SOLD!

Lloyd's Hungry Jack SOLD!

Keeling's St John Wiggler SOLD!

Yellow Hinkle Lizard In Box SOLD!

CCBC Rainbow Castrola In Box SOLD!

Heddon Natural Scale Baby Crab Wiggler SOLD!

CCBC Special Order Nite Glo Surfster In Box SOLD!

Pflueger Strawberry Spot Surprise Minnow SOLD!

Heddon White Shore Stingaree SOLD!

Heddon Natural Scale Flipper In Box SOLD!

Bagley Goldfish Kil R B' SOLD!

Moonlight Perch Pikaroon SOLD!

Haas Liv Minno SOLD!

Creek Chub Black & White Crawdad In Box SOLD!

Bud Stewart Crippled Mouse Wiggler In Box SOLD!

Heddon Natural Finish Top Sonic SOLD!

Creek Chub Goldfish Peter's Special SOLD!

Pflueger Argyle Wizard In Box SOLD!

Heddon Luminous Old Style Torpedo SOLD!

Heddon Baby Popeye MOC SOLD!

Heddon Crappie Punkinseed SOLD!

Shur Strike Concave Belly Darter SOLD!

South Bend Copper Scale Fish Oreno SOLD!

Creek Chub Frog Spot Weedbug SOLD!

Heddon Natural Frog Lucky 13 SOLD!

Harvey Weighted Finned Minnow In Box SOLD!

Pflueger Wizard Minnow SOLD!

Heddon Fly Rod Poppers SOLD!

Arbogast Hula Hoople MOC SOLD!

Immell Bait Company Chippewa SOLD!

Creek Chub Blue Head Spinning Darter SOLD!

Red Hinkle Lizard SOLD!

Heddon Red Scale Crab Wiggler SOLD!

Heddon Pearl Vamp In Box SOLD!

Heddon Yellow Shore Punkinseed In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Purple Eel Pikie In Box SOLD!

Heddon No Eye Lucky 13 in Frog Scale SOLD!

Orvis Travel Bag SOLD!

CCBC Solid Black Baby Pikie In Box SOLD!

Heddon Fish Flash Chugger SOLD!

Paw Paw Bonehead Popper SOLD!

Peetz Wooden Reel In Box SOLD!

CCBC Wigglefish in Rainbow Fire SOLD!

Creek Chub Orange Spotted Baby Pikie SOLD!

CCBC Cohokie In Box SOLD!

Heddon Hedd Hunter MOC SOLD!

Arbogast Jitterbug in Pearl Herringbone SOLD!

Creek Chub White W/ Blush Weedbug SOLD!

Donaly Black Shore Red Fin Floater SOLD!

Creek Chub Rainbow Fire 7000 In Box SOLD!

Joe Pepper Baby Roamer SOLD!

Heddon Black Shore Crazy Crawler SOLD!

Pflueger Hole Eye Surprise Minnow SOLD!

Creek Chub Green & Yellow Beetle SOLD!

Chase A Bug Lure In Box SOLD!

CCBC Dingbat Black Body White Head SOLD!

Heddon Multiple Minnow Nickel Finish SOLD!

Jamison Red & White Wig L Twin In Box SOLD!

Bud Stewart Musky Hammer Handle SOLD!

Paw Paw Crawdad In The Box SOLD!

Greer's Patent Fish Lever Hook SOLD!

Heddon 150 Red/White/Red SOLD!

Creek Chub Silver Flash Sarasota SOLD!

Beik Manufacturing Agitator SOLD!

Creek Chub Plastic Pikie In Rainbow Fire SOLD!

Moonlight Red & White Pikaroon SOLD!

Heddon Uncataloged Budweiser Hi Tail In The Box SOLD!

Heddon Punkin Spin In White Shore SOLD!

Medleys Wiggly Crawfish SOLD!

Creek Chub Red & White Beetle SOLD!

Blue Glitter Goo Goo Eyes In The Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Husky Injured Minnow In Mullet SOLD!

CC Roberts Little Mudpuppy In Picture Box SOLD!

Shakespeare Jack Smith In Photo Finish SOLD!

Creek Chub Rainbow Fire Baby Pikie SOLD!

South Bend Better Bass Oreno SOLD!

Creek Chub Purple Eel Pikie SOLD!

Creek Chub Goldfish Wiggler SOLD!

Buckeye Bait Rainbow Trout Bug N Bass In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Goldfish Injured Minnow SOLD!

Smitty Crawpappy In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Tarpon Pikie SOLD!

Heddon Hi Tail in Silver Flitter SOLD!

1938 Heddon Catalog SOLD!


Abu Garcia 5500 Brown Reel SOLD!

Creek Chub GE Bumble Bee Pikie SOLD!

Pflueger Frog Spot Pop Rite In Box SOLD!

CCBC Pikie Nite Glow w/Red Head SOLD!

Lane's Wagtail Wobbler SOLD!

Heddon Solid Yellow Crab Wiggler SOLD!

Creek Chub Rainbow Wagtail SOLD!

Paw Paw Perch Weedless Wow In Box SOLD!

Heddon Glass Eyed Perch Zaragossa SOLD!

CCBC White Scale Pop N Dunk In Box SOLD!

Howe's Vacuum Bait In Tin SOLD!

Heddon Strawberry Spot Spin Diver SOLD!

Calumet Spiral Lure In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Pickerel Pikie SOLD!

CCBC Special Order Pearl Pikie In Box SOLD!

Pair Of Two Arnold Lures SOLD!


Creek Chub Pikie In Mullet SOLD!

Heddon Blue Scale Gamefisher In Box SOLD!

CCBC Black Head White Body Pikie GE SOLD!

Heddon Big Tiger in Silver Flitter SOLD!

Creek Chub Blue Flash Snook Plunker In Box SOLD!

Arbogast Brown Wheedler In Box SOLD!

Shakespeare Frog Spot Waukazoo SOLD!

R K Tackle Green & Yellow Hollowhead SOLD!

CCBC Dace Husky Injured Minnow SOLD!

Pflueger Kent Frog SOLD!

Heddon Red Head Flitter Basser SOLD!

Creek Chub Strawberry Spot Injured Minnow SOLD!

Reeal Lures Roman Sizzler In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Yellow Flash Pikie In Box SOLD!

Jensen Underwater Froglegs In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Victory Bomber In Box SOLD!

Paw Paw Crawdad In Box SOLD!

Heddon Saltwater Special Red Head Flitter SOLD!

Pflueger Solid Red Neverfail Minnow in White Box SOLD!

Donaly Red Fin Floater SOLD!

Heddon Black Shore Punkinseed In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Orange Spotted Pikie In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Western Auto Red Head Shiner Dinger SOLD!

Heddon Solid Yellow No Eye Lucky 13 SOLD!

Strikemaster Mr. Death SOLD!

Heddon Goldfish Spin Diver SOLD!

Creek Chub GE Tiger Stripe Pikie In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Gar In Box SOLD!

South Bend Fin Dingo SOLD!

Heddon River Runt in Brown Fish Flash SOLD!

CCBC Day N Nite Injured Minnow SOLD!

Heddon Solid Black Crab Wiggler In Box SOLD!

Lot Of Bear Creek Decoys SOLD!

Creek Chub Fireplug Baby Pikie In Box SOLD!

Moonlight 99% Weedless SOLD!

Heddon Goldfish Basser SOLD!

CCBC Silver Flash Musky Darter SOLD!

Creek Chub Pearl Dinger SOLD!

Arbogast Plastic Lip Jitterbug In Box SOLD!

Creek Chub Purple Eel Snook Plunker GE SOLD!

Shakespeare Nu Crip Minnow SOLD!

Creek Chub Pearl Plunker In Box SOLD!

Heddon Red Head Zig Wag SOLD!

Heddon Glass Eye Torpedo In Box SOLD!

CCBC Deep Diving GE Black Scale Pikie In Box SOLD!

Buckeye Bait Yellow Coachdog Bug N Bass SOLD!

Bud Stewart Crippled Wiggler SOLD!

Heddon Florida Special SOLD!

Creek Chub Polywiggle SOLD!

Heddon Frog Scale Baby Crab Wiggler In Box SOLD!

Florida Lure Leaping Lena In Box SOLD!


Commit to the Lord whatever you do, and your plans will succeed. Proverbs 16:3


Click here to go to the Second Sold Lures page


To sign up for our monthly email showing new
lures available, please enter your name and email address
in the boxes below then click on "SIGN ME UP!"

Name: Email Address:





~~I am adding new lures all of the time so check back often!~~